Customers Also Bought: 73% of Shoppers Add These Must-Have Items – See Why!

Post by Aaron 223

Mar 10 2025

Cross-selling sections – those product suggestion boxes typically found under an e-commerce “Buy” button – can significantly boost sales if executed well.

The wording of the section title (e.g. “Pair Well With”, “Frequently Bought Together”, etc.) plays an important role in catching the shopper’s attention and framing the recommendations.

Optimizing these titles is worthwhile: research shows product recommendations account for up to 31% of e-commerce revenues, and visitors who click recommended items convert at 5.5× the rate of others, (thegood.com).

Amazon’s own recommendation engine famously drives 35% of its sales (evdelo.com), underscoring how effective well-presented cross-sells can be.

This report examines what title phrases statistically lead to more conversions in these cross-sell sections, drawing on general e-commerce data, Amazon’s practices, A/B test insights, and industry examples.

Why Title Wording Matters for Conversions

Seemingly small wording changes can have surprisingly large effects on user behavior. In one case, simply using “Buy Now” instead of “Shop Now” on a product page increased click-throughs by 17% (wordstream.com).

The title of a cross-sell box sets the context for the suggested items – it can invite the shopper to engage or be ignored.

Effective titles often leverage psychological triggers like social proof or FOMO (fear of missing out). For example, labeling a section “Customers Also Bought” taps into social proof, subtly telling shoppers that others added these items too.

This influence is powerful: people tend to look at what others bought as an indicator of a product’s value.

On the other hand, a generic phrase like “You May Also Like” provides no specific reason or urgency to consider the items.

As one conversion expert notes, “bland explanations like ‘you may also like’ won’t hit the mark because shoppers already know what they want” (convertcart.com).

In short, the wording needs to quickly communicate relevance or benefit.

A well-chosen title can increase the likelihood that a customer explores and adds complementary products, thereby raising average order value and conversion rates.

Given that effective cross-selling can lift sales by up to 30% according to industry studies (carthook.com), it’s critical to optimize not just which products are shown, but how the cross-sell offer is communicated.

High-Performing Cross-Sell Section Titles

E-commerce leaders have converged on a few proven phrases for cross-sell sections. These titles generally fall into a few categories: social proof driven, complementary benefit driven, or personalized suggestion.

Below, we break down common titles and what studies or tests say about their performance:

“Customers Also Bought” / “People Who Bought This Also Bought”: This phrasing emphasizes that the recommendations are based on real purchase data from other customers (social proof).

It’s a staple on sites like Amazon and Walmart. Amazon prominently displays a “Customers who bought this item also bought” carousel on product pages, and retailers like Under Armour use “Customers Also Bought” to suggest items frequently purchased together on their site.
The social proof element builds trust – if many buyers of Product A also bought Product B, new shoppers infer Product B is worthwhile.

Cross-sell sections framed this way have been very effective at nudging extra purchases.

For instance, Williams Sonoma uses a “Customers Also Bought” section to recommend complementary items (viewing a pasta maker will show a drying rack, cookbook, etc.), leveraging purchase data to increase basket size.

This approach not only increases average order value but also feels natural rather than pushy, since it mirrors how in-store shoppers often pick up related items. Amazon’s huge success with recommendation-driven sales (approximately 35% of sales) is largely attributed to such “customers also bought” suggestions (evdelo.com).

In practice, social-proof titles like these are consistently high-performers for conversion. They provide a clear, trust-building message that the items are popular complements, which encourages more shoppers to add them.
“Frequently Bought Together”: This title explicitly signals that the products are commonly purchased as a bundle with the main item. It implies a high degree of relevance and convenience – the shopper can get everything they likely need in one go.

Amazon’s famous “Frequently Bought Together” section (often placed directly below the product info) is a prime example.

It usually shows 2–3 items (the main product plus add-ons) with a combined price and a one-click “Add all to Cart” button. This strategy is extremely effective at driving upsells – according to one report, leveraging Amazon’s “Frequently Bought Together” feature can boost a product’s sales by 35–40% (ppspy.com).
Many e-commerce platforms and big-box retailers have adopted this terminology because it works.

The wording “Frequently Bought Together” is straightforward and promises utility: it tells shoppers these combinations make sense. Magento and BigCommerce guides even explicitly recommend labeling such bundles as “Frequently Bought Together” to maximize conversion and intuitiveness.

By highlighting frequent combinations, you tap into shoppers’ desire not to “miss” something that others found useful with the item.

In short, this title sets an expectation of “you’ll likely want these together”, which often translates into higher attachment rates per order.

Any store selling products that naturally pair with accessories or add-ons (electronics with batteries, camera with lens, etc.) can benefit from using a “Frequently Bought Together” section title for cross-sells.

It conveys relevance instantly and has become an industry-standard phrase precisely because of its strong performance.

“You May Also Like”: This is one of the most common generic titles for recommending additional products. It’s easy to implement and has broad application – companies like Adidas and Under Armour include “You Might Also Like” sections on product pages to show related or similar items.
However, data and expert opinions suggest that this generic phrasing tends to be less persuasive for cross-selling complementary items.

The phrase “you may also like” doesn’t tell the customer why they might like the suggestions; it’s a soft nudge with no specific value proposition. If the goal is to upsell accessories or companion products (rather than just show alternatives), this wording can underperform more targeted titles.

In fact, B2C conversion specialists advise caution here: “The strategy should be to tread lightly with ‘You might also like’ options” – only use it if you’re confident the item truly adds value for the customer (demandfarm.com).

Essentially, a random “you may also like” list risks feeling like unpersonalized filler, which shoppers might ignore.

That said, this title can still work well when the recommendations are highly personalized (e.g. based on browsing history or style preferences) or when suggesting similar products in case the current item isn’t a perfect fit. It’s frequently used for showing related styles or “people also viewed” items.

For cross-selling (add-on sales), though, many tests have found that more specific copy outperforms a vague “you may also like” label (convertcart.com).

In summary, while “You May Also Like” is ubiquitous, it tends to be less effective at driving immediate add-on conversions unless the context makes the benefit obvious.

Retailers often achieve better results by replacing or augmenting this title with language that highlights relevance or popularity (for example, sites like REI pair a social-proof section – “People who bought this also bought” – with a separate “You may also like” for similar items (omnisend.com), covering both complementary and alternative suggestions).
Benefit-Focused Titles (e.g. “Goes Great With…”, “Complete the Look”, “You May Also Need”): Many retailers are experimenting with phrasing that explicitly highlights the benefit or context of the add-on products.

The idea is to communicate why the customer should consider the recommendations.

For instance, “Complete the Look” is popular in fashion e-commerce – Adidas uses a “Complete the Look” section to suggest apparel that together create a cohesive outfit (e.g. recommending matching shorts and cleats to go with a soccer jersey).
This phrase works well in apparel because it appeals to the shopper’s desire to have a finished ensemble, not just an individual item.

Another example from home furnishings is “You May Also Need” – Pottery Barn uses this title on product pages for furniture to suggest related items that a customer might find essential, like care kits or matching decor for a chair (omnisend.com).

By saying “need,” it frames the add-ons as potentially necessary complements.

These benefit-driven titles often outperform generic ones because they speak to the customer’s use-case.

A study on cross-sell copy found that phrasing like “Goes great with…” tended to trigger higher engagement than “You may also like,” since it emphasizes how the main product and suggested item work together ( convertcart.com).

Essentially, it answers “what’s in it for me?” – e.g. this camera lens goes great with the camera in your cart (to help you take better photos).

Phrases like “Pairs well with” (common for food, wine, or apparel), “Complete your set”, or “Don’t forget these” similarly highlight that the shopper’s experience will be improved by adding these items.

These titles tap into FOMO or the desire for completeness (nobody wants to buy a camera and then realize they forgot the memory card).

In practice, industry-specific phrasing works best: sporting goods retailers might use titles like “Gear up with these extras,” cosmetics brands often say “Wear it with” or “Complete your routine,” and electronics sites might use “Recommended Accessories.”

The key is that these titles contextualize the cross-sell as part of a better overall purchase.

They have been shown to increase uptake of add-ons by making the suggestion feel like genuine help rather than an upsell.

In summary, consider benefit-oriented titles that fit your product category – they can increase cross-sell conversion by clearly conveying relevance and value to the customer.
Personalized Titles (e.g. using the customer’s name or behavior): While less common directly under the “buy” button, some sites tailor the cross-sell section title if data is available – for example, “Recommended for You, [Name]” or “Because you purchased X…”.

These highly personalized touches can grab attention, but they require confidence in your recommendation engine’s relevance.

A Salesforce analysis found that although only 7% of visits engage with a recommendation, those visits account for 24% of orders (thegood.com),
meaning that getting a click on a recommendation is very valuable. If personalization increases those clicks, it can boost conversions.

However, personalized headings are more often seen in email recommendations or account dashboards than on product pages (where the recommendations are tied to a specific product).

For product page cross-sells, it may be more effective to use the product-focused approaches above (e.g. “Frequently Bought Together”) which leverage overall user behavior data. One compromise is using dynamic social proof in the title – for example, a heading like “73% of customers who bought [Product] also bought this”.

This kind of title was the subject of an A/B test on one upsell platform, pitting it against a generic “Frequently Bought Together” to measure which drives more add-on conversions.

The idea is to combine personalization (showing a specific statistic relevant to that product) with social proof.

While results vary, this approach can be extremely persuasive if the data point is compelling. It essentially quantifies the social proof, which can trigger a bandwagon effect – e.g. “wow, 73% of other buyers got that item too – maybe I should really consider it!”.

If your store has the data to support such claims, testing a statistic-based title could yield a noticeable uptick in cross-sell conversion.

Just ensure the stat is truthful and meaningful; if it’s too low or obviously fabricated, it could backfire.

In summary, personalization in titles isn’t always necessary for cross-sells, but when done (either by naming the user or citing user data) it should reinforce trust and relevance to be effective.

Amazon’s Insights on Cross-Sell Titles

Amazon is the gold standard in cross-selling, and their approach offers useful clues. Notably, Amazon typically uses data-driven, no-nonsense titles for its recommendation sections – because they’ve learned what customers respond to at scale.

On Amazon product pages, the two prominent cross-sell sections are “Frequently Bought Together” and “Customers who bought this item also bought”.

Both have been honed over years and billions of interactions to maximize added cart items.

Amazon’s choice of these titles suggests that clarity and social proof win. “Frequently Bought Together” directly tells shoppers these items are commonly bought in the same purchase; “Customers who bought X also bought Y” explicitly ties the recommendation to others’ behavior (leveraging social proof and Amazon’s vast purchase history).

The success of these approaches is reflected in Amazon’s sales – recommendations (which include these cross-sells) contribute roughly 35% of Amazon’s total sales (evdelo.com), a jaw-dropping figure.

Even if your store is not Amazon, the lesson is that Amazon’s users have been conditioned to trust and act on such sections.

Many shoppers now expect to see “frequently bought together” suggestions and may give them credence simply because Amazon uses that format widely.

Amazon has also experimented with placement and wording.

For example, the “Frequently Bought Together” box is placed very near the top of the page (just under the main product details) and visually designed to encourage adding all items with one click.

The title itself is concise and factual, which likely tests better than something overtly salesy.

Interestingly, Amazon sometimes tweaks phrasing for specific contexts – e.g. on some pages you might see “Buy it with” as a simpler call-to-action style heading for an add-on bundle (essentially the same concept as FBT).

This indicates they continuously optimize microcopy.

While Amazon hasn’t published A/B test results of their section titles publicly (they are notoriously data-driven but secretive), their consistent use of these phrases implies they are top performers for conversion.

Moreover, third-party Amazon sellers actively try to game their way into the “Frequently Bought Together” section because it can boost an individual product’s sales by up to ~35–40% once it appears there (ppspy.com).

That indirectly shows how powerful the cross-sell placement and its trusted title are on Amazon’s platform.

For anyone looking for Amazon-specific guidance, a few insights stand out:

(1) Use plain language that reflects real customer behavior (Amazon’s terms are literal and data-backed, which users trust).

(2) Social proof is key – phrases including “customers” or “together” imply community buying patterns that reassure shoppers.

(3) Consider combining the cross-sell offer with a frictionless UI (Amazon pairs the title with convenient checkboxes/add-all buttons – while not a wording change per se, it complements the title to drive action).

In summary, Amazon’s best-performing titles “Frequently Bought Together” and “Customers Also Bought” are a safe starting point for any e-commerce site, given their proven effectiveness at scale.

Just remember to tailor them if needed to fit your audience – Amazon’s broad phrasing works for mass market, but your niche might respond to something more specific (as long as you keep the clarity and social proof elements intact).

A/B Testing Title Variations – What Works Best?

When it comes to cross-sell section titles, testing is crucial.

Different audiences or product categories might respond better to different wording, so it’s wise to run A/B tests on your site just as Amazon and others have done behind the scenes.

Experts routinely advise trying alternate phrasings for recommendation headers to see which yields higher engagement (blog.thecrowdfundingformula.com).

For example, one suggested experiment is to test “You May Also Like” vs “Customers Also Bought” and measure which leads to more add-to-cart actions.

Another real-world test compared a standard “Frequently Bought Together” header against a more specific message: “73% of customers also bought ___” (help.upsellplus.com).

The hypothesis was that adding a concrete statistic (social proof quantification) might outperform the generic title in driving conversions. These kinds of tests are relatively easy to set up and can directly show which wording increases click-through or add-on purchase rate.

The results of title A/B tests often confirm that small wording tweaks can produce measurable gains.

If Variation A gets even a few percentage points more users to consider the recommendations than Variation B, that can translate to a big revenue difference over time.

We’ve seen analogous outcomes in other UI copy tests – for instance, changing a few words in a product page tagline yielded a 107% lift in conversions in one case study (wordstream.com).

While that example wasn’t a cross-sell title, it illustrates the scale of impact microcopy optimization can have on e-commerce behavior.

In the context of cross-selling, you might find that “Don’t miss out – Frequently Bought Together:” outperforms a plain “Frequently Bought Together”, or vice versa, depending on your customers.

Some sites have found success in making the title feel more like a helpful note, e.g. “Complete your order with these recommended add-ons”, whereas others do better with terse headings. The only way to know is to test with real users.

When A/B testing cross-sell titles, keep these best practices in mind:

Test one element at a time: To isolate the effect of the title text, keep the product suggestions and design constant between variants, only changing the heading wording.
That way any conversion difference can be attributed to the copy.
Run tests for sufficient duration/samples: Because conversion uplifts might be small in absolute percentage terms, ensure you gather enough data (e.g. let the test run until you have at least 30+ conversions from the cross-sell for each variant as a rough rule).
This guards against false positives.
Measure meaningful metrics: Track add-to-cart rate from the cross-sell section or overall average order value uplift. It’s also useful to see click-through rates on the recommendation links. A title that encourages more exploration (clicks) is usually a positive sign, as long as it doesn’t distract from the main purchase.
Consider segmenting by device: Sometimes a phrase might perform differently on mobile vs desktop (due to screen space or context). If resources allow, test on both or ensure the winning copy works well on all devices.
Gather qualitative feedback if possible: Tools like heatmaps or session recordings can show if users scroll past the section or engage with it under different titles. You could even run a quick user survey or preference test (services like PickFu have been used to gauge which phrasing seems more appealing to customers in theory).

In published experiments, social-proof oriented and benefit-oriented titles tend to beat neutral ones for cross-selling purposes.

For example, a CRO agency found that reframing a generic recommendation as a more specific benefit (essentially changing the title to highlight why the items should be bought together) led to more interactions (convertcart.com).

If you don’t have huge traffic to test multiple options, you can leverage these insights: start with a proven phrase (like those Amazon uses or something that clearly communicates value) as your default, then test incremental improvements on it (like adding a percentage, or a phrasing tweak).

Over time, this data-driven refinement can yield significant conversion improvements on your site’s cross-sell performance.

Industry-Specific Insights

Effective cross-sell titles can also vary by industry. Different retail verticals have developed their own conventions for phrasing add-on recommendations in a way that resonates with their customers.

Here are a few industry-specific observations:

Fashion and Apparel: As mentioned, “Complete the Look” is a highly effective title in the fashion world. Shoppers buying clothing are often receptive to styling suggestions.

For example, Adidas’ product pages show a “Complete the Look” section with items that pair with the one being viewed (creating a full outfit).
This not only increases conversion on those items but enhances customer satisfaction by showing how pieces work together. Similarly, apparel retailers sometimes use “Wear it With” or “Shop the Outfit”.

These titles perform well because they tap into the desire to have a coordinated look. They imply by getting these additional pieces, you’ll have a stylish ensemble.

Fashion retailers also often include “You Might Also Like” sections, but as a separate module for related styles – the conversion-driven cross-sell is usually the “complete the look” (complementary items) section, since that directly drives additional units per order.

Social proof language is used too (Under Armour uses “Customers Also Bought” on product pages for sports apparel), which can reassure shoppers about popular gear combinations.

But overall, emphasizing the fashion benefit(completeness of an outfit or accessory that enhances the main item) tends to be most effective in this category.
Consumer Electronics: In electronics and tech, customers respond to phrasing that highlights practical necessities or upgrades.

Titles like “Frequently Bought Together” are common on electronics sites, often to suggest accessories (cables, cases, batteries) that go with a device. For instance, an online electronics store might show a “Frequently Bought Together” bundle for a camera with a memory card and bag – this straightforward approach works because tech buyers appreciate knowing what accessories are commonly needed (and it mirrors Amazon’s style which is familiar to them).

Another tactic is using titles like “Recommended Accessories” or “You May Also Need” for tech products. Pottery Barn’s “You May Also Need” for home goods was mentioned,
and the same principle applies in electronics (e.g. “You May Also Need: 2 AA batteries” for a gadget).

The key for electronics is the title should signal necessity or smart pairing, as opposed to something whimsical. Tech shoppers are often task-oriented; a title that implies “don’t forget this add-on” can effectively increase conversion.

Also, warranties or protection plans are a form of cross-sell in this industry – retailers like Target and Walmart use pop-ups with titles that clearly state the offer (e.g., “Add a Protection Plan” rather than a coy “You might like…”).

The conversion data here shows that being direct and value-focused (protect your purchase, complete your setup, etc.) yields higher take rates on these offers (omnisend.com).

Home Goods and Furniture: Home goods retailers use a mix of social proof and needs-based titles. We saw Williams Sonoma use “Customers Also Bought” to suggest kitchen tool add-ons,
which likely improves conversion by showing popular combos (e.g. attachments for a stand mixer).

Meanwhile, Pottery Barn’s “You May Also Need” specifically targets add-ons that ensure the customer has everything for their new furniture piece (cleaners, extra covers, etc.).

Another pattern in home décor is “Customers Also Viewed” or “Goes well with” for decorative complements – though these may be less conversion-driving and more exploratory.

For increasing actual cross-sell conversion, phrases that highlight utility or completeness perform best in this vertical. For example, a bedding store might use “Complete Your Bed Set” as a title to sell matching pillows and sheets with a duvet – framing it as completing a set encourages the customer to add all components (which can improve conversion significantly by turning a single-item purchase into a bundled sale).

In the furniture space, where items are higher ticket, customers also appreciate guidance – titles like “Frequently Bought Together” (e.g. table with chairs) or “You may also need – Tools & Care” can prompt adds that the customer might otherwise overlook, thus boosting the conversion on those cross-sells.
Grocery and Food/Beverage: In grocery e-commerce or wine/food retail, cross-sells often use the language of pairing.

Titles such as “Pairs Well With”, “Great With [Product]”, or “Frequently Bought Together” are common. For instance, an online wine shop might have a section titled “Pairs well with this wine” suggesting cheeses or crackers.

These phrasing choices leverage the idea of complementing flavors or usage occasions, which can increase conversion by appealing to the customer’s desire for a better overall experience (wine + cheese, chips + dip, etc.).

The data in this domain is often tied to basket analysis – if a high percentage of people who buy salsa also buy chips, labeling that recommendation as “Often Bought Together” or “Don’t forget the chips!” can significantly uplift the attach rate.

While formal studies specific to grocery wording are rare, general principles show that explicit pairing suggestions outperform generic ones here.

The cross-sell title effectively serves as a serving suggestion or meal idea, which can inspire additional purchases.

So, using phrasing that reflects that (even something like “Make it a Meal:” on a prepared foods site) can boost conversions and average order value.

It’s clear that across industries, the winning titles speak the customer’s language and address their needs.

Whether it’s fashion or tech, a title that aligns with why the customer might truly want the add-on will convert better. Industries selling utilitarian products lean on straightforward titles with social proof or necessity (customers also bought, you need this), while lifestyle industries inject a bit more creative phrasing (complete the look, pairs well with).

Nonetheless, the underlying strategy is the same: make the cross-sell feel like a helpful recommendation rather than a sales pitch.

Conversion Impact and Key Statistics

To quantify the impact of optimizing cross-sell section titles, it’s useful to look at some conversion rate improvement figures from studies and experiments:

Conversion Rate Uplift from Recommendations: First, simply having these cross-sell recommendations is a proven boon.

Barilliance found that shoppers who clicked on product recommendations (e.g. in “customers also bought” sections) converted 5½ times higher than those who didn’t interact with recommendations (thegood.com).
This isn’t solely due to the title text, but it underscores that getting users to notice and click your cross-sell section can dramatically raise conversions. A compelling title is what draws that attention.
Sales Contribution: As noted earlier, product recommendations can drive a large share of revenue – up to 31% per some research.
In Amazon’s case, 35% of purchases are influenced by their recommendation engine (evdelo.com).

While these percentages are not isolated to title changes, they highlight how critical these sections under the buy button are for conversions and repeat sales.
Impact of Specific Title Changes: Precise A/B test results on cross-sell phrasing are not always public, but analogies from other tests show significant impacts.

For example, changing a homepage recommendation widget’s title from a generic to a social-proof variant could easily boost click-through or add-to-cart rates by double-digit percentages.

Anecdotally, optimization agencies have reported 10–30% increases in sales from well-implemented upsell/cross-sell strategies (carthook.com).
One Amazon-focused report claimed sellers could increase their sales by “up to 35-40%” by appearing in the “Frequently Bought Together” section (ppspy.com) (effectively the result of Amazon’s algorithm deciding your product is frequently bought with another).

This gives a sense of the order of magnitude when cross-sells are done right.
Microcopy Test Gains: As mentioned, even minor wording shifts can yield measurable conversion lifts. The 17% higher clicks for “Buy Now” vs “Shop Now” and the 107% jump in conversions from a trust-message change (wordstream.com) serve as reminders that words matter.

In the context of cross-sells, if a new title encourages even a few percent more of visitors to examine the recommended items, that could raise overall conversion proportionally.

For instance, if currently 5% of product page visitors add a recommended item, and a wording tweak increases that to 6%, that’s a 20% relative increase in cross-sell conversion – which might translate to a several percent increase in total sales for that product page.

Such improvements are significant in e-commerce terms.
Examples of Phrasing Impact: A/B tests on phrasing like “Recommended for you” vs “Customers also bought” have shown the latter (social proof) often performing better in terms of additional products added to cart.
Similarly, some retailers reported higher attachment rates when switching from “You may also like” to more directive or benefit-oriented language (“Complete your set” etc.), although exact percentages vary by case.

The consistency of positive feedback in case studies suggests that a well-optimized title can easily add a few percentage points to conversion rate or boost average order value by 5–10% in many scenarios.

These gains compound: higher AOV and slightly higher conversion due to cross-sells can significantly improve revenue per visitor.

It’s important to note that the conversion rate we’re improving here can be viewed in two ways: the conversion of the cross-sell itself (i.e. what % of people add the extra item) and the overall page conversion (buying the main item, perhaps with extras).

A good cross-sell title should improve the former without hurting the latter. For example, a too-aggressive upsell title could, in theory, distract or annoy customers and reduce main product conversion – but the titles we’ve discussed (frequently bought together, etc.) generally complement the sale rather than divert it.

When optimized, they tend to either have neutral or positive impact on the main product conversion while significantly lifting the take rate of additional items.

That means pure upside for revenue and a better customer experience (since customers get all they need). Monitoring these metrics during tests will ensure the title change is truly beneficial.

Practical Recommendations for Title Selection

Based on the research and data above, here are actionable recommendations for choosing and optimizing your cross-selling section titles:

Leverage Social Proof: Whenever possible, use wording that indicates other customers’ behavior. Titles like “Customers Also Bought” or “People Who Bought X Also Bought” capitalize on social proof and tend to build trust.

Shoppers feel more confident adding an item if they know others did the same. This approach works across many industries and is backed by Amazon’s and others’ success.
Highlight Complementary Benefits: Make it clear the suggested items will enhance or complete the main purchase. Phrases such as “Frequently Bought Together”, “Complete the Look”, “Goes Great With [Product]”, or “You May Also Need” explicitly communicate relevance or added value
This framing answers the “why” for the customer – e.g. these items go well together, so you won’t regret adding them. Benefit-oriented titles can outperform generic suggestions, as they resonate with the customer’s needs.
Avoid Vague or Uninspiring Titles: Steer away from overly generic headings like “Products” or even “You May Also Like” unless you have a good reason. If using “You May Also Like”, ensure the content is highly relevant or personalized; otherwise consider a stronger hook. As experts warn, a bland “you may also like” can be ignored if it doesn’t clearly help the shopper (demandfarm.com).
Always ask: does my title give a shopper a reason to care about these items? If not, refine it.
Tailor Language to Your Audience/Industry: One size doesn’t fit all. Use
terminology that aligns with your product category and customer mindset.

For example, for fashion/apparel, use creative styling language (“Complete Your Outfit”, “Style It With”); for electronics, be straightforward (“Recommended Accessories”, “Frequently Bought Together”); for home decor, maybe suggest ideas (“Customers Also Bought – Complete Your Room”).

The title should feel natural in the context of your site. Industry examples show that aligning the phrasing with the shopping context (technical, lifestyle, gourmet, etc.) yields better engagement. E.g., Adidas’s “Complete the Look” works for apparel,
while Pottery Barn’s “You May Also Need” suits home goods.
Consider Quantifying or Personalizing (Carefully): If you have strong data, try adding it into the title to boost credibility. For instance, “Frequently Bought Together – 85% of shoppers add these” or “Popular Pairing: X% of customers also buy…”.

An UpsellPlus experiment exactly suggested testing a title like “73% of customers also bought…” against a plain heading (help.upsellplus.com).

We tested it, that's why you are here 😉
Such specifics can grab attention and instill FOMO. Just ensure any statistic used is accurate and meaningful; false or trivial stats could erode trust.

Personalization (like using the customer’s name or referencing their history) in the title is less common on product pages, but you could do something like “[CustomerName], you might love these with your new X” if your site recognizes logged-in users.

This can create a feeling of a curated, personal recommendation, which can improve engagement if not overdone.
Keep Titles Concise and Clear: Users typically scan pages, so the cross-sell header should be short enough to grasp at a glance.

Aim for just a few words or a brief phrase. Most effective titles are in the range of 2–4 words(not counting terms like “your” or “with”) – e.g. “Frequently Bought Together”, “You May Also Need”. If you do use a longer phrase (say a full sentence like “Customers who bought this item also bought these”), make sure it’s broken up or styled in a way that’s easily readable.

Clarity beats cleverness here; the title’s job is to immediately convey “here are complementary items worth considering”.
Test and Iterate: Don’t rely on gut feeling – run A/B tests for different title options to see which drives the most conversions on your site.
Start with a solid default (informed by the research above), then experiment. For example, you might test “Customers Also Bought” vs “Complete Your Purchase:” vs “You May Also Like” to see which yields a higher cross-sell take rate.

Or test adding an emoji or icon with the title (some sites use a ⚡ or + symbol next to “Frequently Bought Together” to draw attention). Monitor metrics like the cross-sell section’s click-through rate and the percentage of orders that include a recommended item.

Even a modest improvement can be meaningful – recall that one word change led to a 17% CTR lift in a test (wordstream.com).

Over time, continuously optimize the title as you gather more data about customer behavior.
Ensure Relevance of Recommendations: This isn’t directly about the title wording, but it’s critical: no matter how great your title is, the section won’t convert if the products shown aren’t truly complementary or appealing.

Make sure your cross-sell algorithm or manual selection surfaces items that do “pair well” with the main product.

The title and content should work hand-in-hand. If you use a title like “Goes great with your item”, but the suggestions are random or low-quality, customers will lose trust.

On the flip side, highly relevant suggestions combined with a persuasive title create a seamless experience where users feel the site is genuinely helping them. Monitor engagement – if a certain title is not performing, the issue might be with the products shown as much as the text.
Maintain a Helpful Tone: Framing is everything.

The title should sound helpful, not like an aggressive upsell. Phrases with “recommended”, “customers often buy”, “you might need” etc., have a helpful tone.

Avoid wording that sounds too pushy or self-serving, like “Add these now!” or “More products for you to buy” (extreme example, but you get the idea).

The goal is to make the shopper feel it’s in their interest to consider the items. Amazon’s neutral phrasing again is instructive – it’s factual and not overly promotional.

If your title passes the test of “Would this sound like a helpful tip from a sales associate?”, it’s likely on the right track.

By following these recommendations – using data-backed, customer-centric language and continuously testing – you can select a cross-selling title that maximizes conversions.

A well-optimized title will draw shoppers into exploring complementary products and ultimately increase the proportion of orders with cross-sell additions.

The result is a win-win: higher revenue for the store and a more complete, satisfying purchase for the customer.

Conclusion

In summary, the title of your “Pair Well With” section can meaningfully influence conversion rates in e-commerce.

General data confirms the importance of these sections, as a significant chunk of online revenue (20–30% or more) can flow through product recommendations.

Amazon’s experience shows that using clear, trust-inspiring titles like “Frequently Bought Together” and “Customers Also Bought” yields tremendous success – and many other retailers have mirrored that approach.

A/B testing and case studies suggest that phrases which emphasize social proof or complementary benefits outperform generic labels, often leading to measurable upticks in cross-sell conversion.

Different industries may favor different wording, but the underlying principle is consistent: make the cross-sell feel relevant and valuable to the shopper.

Provide context (e.g. complete the outfit, necessary accessory, popular pairing) and shoppers are more likely to bite. Whenever possible, back the suggestion with evidence (“others bought this”) or reasoning (“you’ll need this because…”).

Finally, remember that optimization is an ongoing process. Use the recommendations and data here as a starting point, but observe your own customers’ behavior and refine accordingly.

Even a small improvement – say a few percentage points increase in people adding that extra item – can translate into a substantial revenue boost over time.

With a clear, data-informed title and truly complementary offerings, your “Pair Well With” section can become a powerful driver of both conversion and customer satisfaction, rather than just a side note on the product page.

By carefully choosing the words that invite shoppers to explore, you set the stage for them to discover more value in every purchase – and that is the essence of effective cross-selling.

- End -